New technical evidence has emerged regarding suspicions that Chinese AI companies have been using NVIDIA's latest GPUs, which are subject to U.S. export restrictions. On November 12, independent research group Unemployment Labs reported finding traces of NVIDIA's "Blackwell" generation GPUs in AI models released by four companies, including DeepSeek. The analysis was conducted by Will DePue, a former OpenAI researcher.

A total of six models released by four companies—DeepSeek, Moonshot AI, MiniMax, and Ant Group—were subject to the investigation. The research team reportedly analyzed the vast numerical data comprising the AI models and discovered characteristics consistent with NVIDIA's "B200," "B300," "GB200," and "GB300" GPUs.

According to the research team, subtle differences arise in the numerical settings at the start of AI training, depending on the GPU used. Some of these differences can remain even after training, effectively acting as a "fingerprint" of the GPU. When the research team validated this with an actual B300, they were able to almost perfectly reproduce the original numerical patterns in 461 out of 469 lines (approximately 98%) of DeepSeek-V4-Flash data. Furthermore, 445 lines reportedly showed a complete numerical match.

However, it is not certain that Blackwell GPUs were used for the entire AI training process, nor could the acquisition channels or installation locations of the GPUs be identified. While similar patterns can also be reproduced with AMD GPUs using special settings, the research team states that they ruled out the possibility of AMD GPUs for DeepSeek-V4-Flash through additional verification.

Made with AI